Questions about interface related design considerations, such as programming to the interface.

learn more… | top users | synonyms (1)

1
vote
1answer
84 views

Use the chance to return booleans after method calls for an optional layer of exception handling? [duplicate]

I would like to ask a follow-up to a question I just asked: Better to have 2 methods with clear meaning, or just 1 dual use method? I now understand why it is best to separate charge(float c); and ...
27
votes
6answers
3k views

Better to have 2 methods with clear meaning, or just 1 dual use method?

To simplify the interface, is it better to just not have the getBalance() method? Passing 0 to the charge(float c); will give the same result: public class Client { private float bal; float ...
2
votes
1answer
249 views

Open / Closed Principle

I found this code example explaining Open / Closed principle. Code before application of principle: public class Logger { public void Log(string message, LogType logType) { switch (...
0
votes
0answers
56 views

Software Architecture: CQRS and port modeling

I have a PersonComponent, which an internal implementation is based on CQRS pattern. So which one is better way to model ports (and their interfaces): I'm not totally sure that how high or low -...
15
votes
3answers
20k views

Why does C# allow properties in interfaces?

In C#, the following code is valid interface I{ int property{get;set;} } Which doesn't make any sense to me. This seems to break one of the most important principles of interfaces: lack of ...
8
votes
3answers
1k views

Is using interfaces for datatypes an anti-pattern?

Suppose I have a various entities in my model (using EF), say User, Product, Invoice and Order. I am writing a user control that can can print the summaries of entity objects in my application where ...
0
votes
1answer
191 views

Neat way on passing interface parameter to a constructor

Having lots of Interface that needs to pass in a constructor looks messy, is there any neat way of doing it? Code snippet: public class Foo { private readonly IRepository1 _repository1; ...
1
vote
2answers
113 views

Does an interface including several methods that return instances of Object make sense?

I am in the process of writing my first true API. In the process, I am defining an interface for mapping complex data structures onto other complex data structures. At the moment, the interface ...
-2
votes
1answer
213 views

Why are interfaces necessary in MVP design pattern?

I am trying to understands MVP using Winforms. I found this example. Why do UserModel and UserView need to implement the IUserModel and IUserView interfaces ?
1
vote
2answers
92 views

Where to inject dependency required by all implementors of an interface?

I have an interface whose job is to communicate with repository (that implements some interface). It doesn't seem to make sense to implement this interface without receiving a repository,so I'd like ...
4
votes
3answers
716 views

Generics vs common interface?

I don't remember when I wrote generic class last time. Every time I think I need it after some thinking I make a conclusion I don't. The second answer to this question made me to ask for ...
0
votes
1answer
130 views

Can I enforce the overriding of GetHashCode() and Equals() methods for users of a generic container class?

I have a container class similar to the one below (with much of the logic omitted): class Container<T> { Dictionary<T, TWrapped> contains = new Dictionary<T, TWrapper>(); ...
1
vote
3answers
306 views

How can I sell DRY? [closed]

Where I work we have around 10 VS projects in a solution which are identical in functionality (with some different different rules in a few methods) and share many exact methods. They share the same ...
2
votes
2answers
74 views

Where to put configuration constants?

Considering a small embedded C project, how to decide if certain constants belong to a global configuration file the header of the "module == compilation unit" on top of the the actual C file or ...
9
votes
2answers
480 views

Interface Segregation Principle: What to do if interfaces have significant overlap?

From Agile Software Development, Principles, Patterns, and Practices: Pearson New International Edition: Sometimes, the methods invoked by different groups of clients will overlap. If the overlap ...
9
votes
2answers
201 views

Programming to Data Oriented Interfaces

There is a portion of our codebase written in the following style: // IScheduledTask.cs public interface IScheduledTask { string TaskName { get; set; } int TaskPriority { get; set; } List&...
6
votes
2answers
311 views

Handling interface segregation in C++

I'm designing a "view" handling system for a game. The goal is to be able to have different "views" that can be shown in sequence or stacked on-top of each other. For example, the initial splash ...
3
votes
3answers
122 views

Interface design - Parameter choice

Situation: Is it better to have one or few parameters that supply more than enough information for the intended process or should you have more specific parameters that provide just enough ...
3
votes
6answers
177 views

If Class is to define attributes and methods, and Interface is to define (a set of) methods, then how to think of interface needing new attributes?

I thought a class is supposed to define, or give a blueprint, of attributes and methods for an object. And then, an interface is to provide a set of methods, as a contract for its clients. (and so a ...
1
vote
4answers
500 views

Implements > extends, but what about variables?

It's preferable to write programs that depend on interfaces rather than on superclasses, but what if you want a class to have certain variables? Sometimes you want a class to implement a certain ...
4
votes
2answers
350 views

How and when did it happen that, a type is an interface?

I came from a highly functional and procedural background in programming, and never knew that a type is the same as an interface. As in the Design Patterns book by GoF, it says: A type is a name ...
21
votes
5answers
2k views

Implementing an interface when you don't need one of the properties

Pretty straight-forward. I'm implementing an interface, but there's one property that is unnecessary for this class and, in fact, shouldn't be used. My initial idea was to just do something like: int ...
3
votes
2answers
225 views

Is Dependency Inversion a valid alternative to the pImpl idiom?

If I want to present to the user of my code an interface, that is unlikely to change, I can write only the public part of the classes in public headers and have a single private pointer to another ...
2
votes
3answers
198 views

What is the purpose of a wrapper class that does nothing but delegate to the object it wraps?

The specific example I have in mind is javax.servlet.ServletResponseWrapper: public class ServletResponseWrapper implements ServletResponse { private ServletResponse response; /** * The ...
21
votes
10answers
5k views

Declaring interface in the same file as the base class, is it a good practice?

To be interchangable and testable, normally services with logic needs to have interface, e.g. public class FooService: IFooService { ... } Design-wise, I agree with this, but one of the things ...
1
vote
1answer
166 views

When should interface be owned by client?

In Agile Software Development: Principles, Patterns, and Practices, Uncle Bob talks about client owning the service interface. My questions are : Should client always own the interface or only ...
0
votes
4answers
386 views

In C#, what is the benefit of assigning a class variable to an interface variable before calling any methods?

Where I work we develop in C# .NET and I was looking a code that they have made (my job is to optimize it) but I saw something in particular: Assuming that InterfaceDHO is an interface and ClassDHO ...
0
votes
2answers
118 views

Best practice for encapsulating a parameter that requires multiple interfaces to be implemented

I encounter this issue multiple times, but I'm never sure how best to deal with it. Basically, some methods I write require the implementing object to support multiple interfaces. The example I have ...
3
votes
3answers
231 views

How to “program to an interface”

I've read these questions: Understanding "programming to an interface" What is the point of an interface? Does it always make sense to "program to an interface" in Java? I don'...
3
votes
3answers
148 views

Communicating to an Object from another without coupling in java?

So I have a Person object, and a GumballMachine object. The behavior I'm searching for is, in the intent to avoid unnecessary coupling, have the method insertCoin() called from within the Person ...
5
votes
3answers
418 views

Composition over inheritance but

I'm trying to teach myself software engineering and coming up against some conflicting information which is confusing me. I've been learning OOP and what abstract classes / Interfaces are and how to ...
4
votes
2answers
330 views

Design interface for WebService to access several MySQL databases

I am currently trying to design an interface for a WebService that can access several MySQL databases. There will be 4 operations available, Add(), Read(), Update() and Delete(). The WebService just ...
3
votes
2answers
556 views

Should the main method be separate in a separate class? [closed]

In Java main methods often do little more than parsing the command line arguments and initializing an object that then takes over, for example: public class FooServer { // ... public static ...
4
votes
1answer
219 views

UML: Should an asynchronous request-response message exchange be modelled as two ports/interfaces or one

I want to model an asynchronous request-response message exchange in UML. The request is sent from a client to a server. The server responses asynchronously. This can be modelled in a component ...
0
votes
0answers
26 views

Text based command/interface design

When using inter-process communication (pipes, memory streams, ...), I typically have a byte stream to communicate, also with http (unless using some heavy-weight web framework), the body comes as a ...
1
vote
2answers
210 views

To god (class) or not to god? [duplicate]

I'm working on a project that requires several different users in the system, all of which have overlapping responsibilities; we've isolated two possible ways of tackling this problem, but we're ...
0
votes
1answer
98 views

When designing input interfaces for a library, when to use data class rather than data interface?

Let's say library A, B and C are all custom math libraries. They may or may not use the same data types. The libraries have methods that accept data type inputs like ProcessAsync(DataTypeA) or ...
1
vote
1answer
142 views

Interface Design: Specific vs General parameter (A Minimal design vs anticipated use variation)

Code public interface IVehicle { string VehicleMake { get; } int MonthsSincePurchase { get; } bool IsApprovedUsed { get; } ... } public class WarrantyPopUpHandler { virtual bool ...
-3
votes
1answer
145 views

Why can't I return an implementation of an interface for a method that requests the interface? [closed]

I am implementing an interface I on a class A. Class A implements I. I have an Iterator T that is supposed to return an object which implements I everytime I call next. My iterator goes as follows (...
4
votes
2answers
408 views

Is this a pattern? Proxy/delegation of interface to existing concrete implementation

I occasionally write code like this when I want to replace small parts of an existing implementation: public interface IFoo { void Bar(); } public class Foo : IFoo { public void Bar() { ...
2
votes
1answer
157 views

Using own ArrayList in general purpose C libraries, but allowing a different implementation

I've written a couple of libraries since beginning to use C again last year. One thing that still needs addressing in both of these is the correct use of array-based lists - hereafter, ArrayLists. At ...
1
vote
2answers
293 views

What are the justifications for annotations in a programming language? [closed]

After spending a great deal of time writing C# and looking at Java, it seems to me that annotations are just an ugly code smell that introduce another conceptual layer that could easily be replaced by ...
0
votes
1answer
163 views

Coding to an interface vs more generic interfaces

I have a number of classes (and interfaces) which 'code to an interface' interface File { ... } interface FileConverter { public function convert(File $file); //coding to an interface ...
2
votes
1answer
81 views

Reusing an interface or method chaining

I am learning about coding to an interface in OOP programming. I understand you should code to an interface so you can 'swap out' functionality. However, I have a situation where I feel I can reuse ...
0
votes
4answers
629 views

How is an interface used in Dependency Injection?

I'm working on a simple DI library, and on the subject of using services through interfaces, I can't find the usefulness. Perhaps it's because I dont fully or properly understand how an interface ...
12
votes
3answers
4k views

Should I implement an interface directly or have the superclass do it?

Is there a difference between public class A extends AbstractB implements C {...} versus... public class A extends AbstractB {...} abstract class AbstractB implements C {...} I understand that ...
2
votes
2answers
422 views

when using dependency injection, should I always pass an interface

When using depending injection, you generally pass everything around as an interface (perhaps with the exception of primitives and strings). That allows you to easily chance the behavior, without ...
5
votes
1answer
496 views

Is using protected inheritance to hide (but exploit) implemented interface from the public ok?

Recently, we had a discussion about code using protected inheritance in order to hide the fact (to client code) a class inherits from a specific base class but to exploit this fact in the ...
5
votes
6answers
4k views

What are good reasons to use explicit interface implementation for the sole purpose of hiding members?

During one of my studies into the intricacies of C#, I came across an interesting passage concerning explicit interface implementation. While this syntax is quite helpful when you need to resolve ...
1
vote
1answer
61 views

MVC .NET APP Program Structure [closed]

I am just building a MVC .NET application, eventually this will use entity framework and the repository pattern to structure the program. The first release however will only be calling other jobs that ...