Reputation
Top tag
Next privilege 200 Rep.
See reduced ads
Badges
7
Newest
 Commentator
Impact
~807 people reached

  • 0 posts edited
  • 1 helpful flag
  • 19 votes cast
Oct
25
accepted Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
Oct
25
revised Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
added 50 characters in body
Oct
25
awarded  Commentator
Oct
25
comment Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
@Caleb Context added.
Oct
25
revised Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
Clarified this is about manual user testing, not simply manual testing
Oct
25
comment Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
I'll clarify the original question to "User testing" from manual testing. Nice catch, thanks!
Oct
25
revised Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
Added more context
Oct
25
awarded  Critic
Oct
25
comment Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
That sounds like you're answering a different but easier question.
Oct
25
comment Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
My intuition of comparing unit tests to manual tests is an apples to oranges problem. Unit tests help flesh out the design and help ease later changes. Manual tests show that the system as a whole is correct in some aspect. It is possible to have a unit test that passes but a manual test that fails. A possibly contrived example would be the code is not actually used in production but is used in a unit test.
Oct
25
comment Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
It seems like your answer starts addressing unit tests and manual tests and ends up discussing automated tests and manual tests as it's final point.
Oct
25
asked Is it dangerous to substitute unit tests for user testing?
Oct
26
comment Noobie wants to use source control, how would you guide them?
But there is certainly utility in narrowing the search space no?
Oct
26
awarded  Teacher
Oct
25
awarded  Editor
Oct
25
awarded  Supporter
Oct
25
comment Noobie wants to use source control, how would you guide them?
Thank you for pointing out a gotcha along the way. I'll come clean, I'm the newbie so this sort of information was part of what I was looking for. +1
Oct
25
awarded  Scholar
Oct
25
accepted Noobie wants to use source control, how would you guide them?
Oct
25
awarded  Student